Email MarketingMarketing

Category Compare: Email Marketing Software vs. SMS Marketing Software

Ashish Upadhyay profile picture
By Ashish Upadhyay

Published | Updated on
6 min read

Compare email marketing and SMS marketing software to decide which one aligns better with your marketing goals.

For your marketing team, it can be confusing to decide whether to use email marketing software or SMS marketing software. Both software tools help spread the word about your small business and reach your target audience, but they operate in different ways and serve different purposes.

While email marketing software lets you promote your offerings via the email channel, SMS marketing software strictly targets mobile users and allows you to send promotional content via text messages.

This article discusses the similarities and differences between email marketing and SMS marketing software so you can select the right one for your marketing needs. For each software category, we’ve also included the top five products based on verified software reviews. Read more.

What is email marketing software?

Email marketing software allows your business to create and run email marketing campaigns to promote your products, services, new launches, events, and more. It lets you create segmented email lists so you can send targeted, relevant content to your subscribers.

The software helps track metrics such as open rate, click-through rate, and conversion to assess how well your email campaigns are performing. You can send personalized emails to promote your offerings, build brand awareness, or increase customer engagement.

Our lists of email marketing agencies by location can help you find the services you’re looking for.

Email marketing features graphic for the blog article "Category Compare: Email Marketing Software vs. SMS Marketing Software"

Core features of email marketing software

The core features of email marketing software are:

Email management:

Helps organize your inbox by categorizing emails using filters such as sender name, subject, and keyword.

List management:

Allows you to create multiple subscriber lists and maintain their quality by flagging and removing inactive or invalid email addresses.

Subscriber management:

Lets you add, edit, or remove subscribers from email lists and segment subscribers based on various criteria such as demographics, interests, and behavior.

5 top-rated email marketing software

These products are listed in alphabetical order. (Check how we selected them.)

*Analysis accurate as of March 2023

What is SMS marketing software?

SMS marketing software provides the tools to launch and run text marketing campaigns to promote your products or services. It enables you to send personalized text messages to a specific audience or bulk messages to a pool of contacts.

The software allows you to create and maintain contact lists, schedule messages, analyze open rates, and generate reports to check engagement levels. You can use text marketing software to advertise weekly specials, send coupons to customers, get feedback, run surveys, and promote contests, among others.

SMS marketing features graphic for the blog article "Category Compare: Email Marketing Software vs. SMS Marketing Software"

Core features of SMS marketing software

The core features of SMS marketing software are:

Contact management:

Offers a centralized repository to store customer details, such as their names, addresses, and phone numbers, in an organized, searchable manner. It lets you create multiple contact lists, add or remove individual contacts from a list, and import or export existing contact lists.

Mass texting:

Enables you to send bulk text messages to a large group of people. Mass texting helps you reach a larger audience and promote sales, events, or other marketing campaigns.

5 top-rated SMS marketing software

These products are listed in alphabetical order. (Check how we selected them.)

*Analysis accurate as of March 2023

Email marketing vs. SMS marketing software: How are they similar?

Email marketing and SMS marketing tools assist marketing and PR teams in delivering promotional content to target audiences. Both help automate communication with prospects or customers, enabling your small business to run targeted marketing campaigns.

Both tools allow you to create targeted contact lists, schedule messages, and track customer engagement levels. You can use both to deliver marketing messages such as shopping deals, account alerts, appointment reminders, brand updates, targeted campaigns, purchase confirmations, and newsletters. 

Contact management, customer segmentation, campaign management, subscriber management, and reporting/analytics are a few features commonly found in both software solutions.

Ready to hire an email marketing agency for your business needs? Browse our list of companies in the following areas:

Email marketing vs. SMS marketing software: Which one is right for your business?

Choosing between email marketing and SMS marketing software depends on various factors, and the age and demographic of your target audience is the most important one. If you’re targeting a younger audience, SMS marketing could be more effective, as youngsters prefer texting over email. But if your audience is diverse, email marketing could be a better choice because it allows you to include more varied, detailed content along with visuals.

Your budget is the next factor. A text message marketing tool could be more expensive than an email marketing tool, as each text message is charged separately. However, pricing for email marketing software usually depends on the size of your email list. If you have a large contact list, email marketing could be a more cost-effective option.

You should also consider your marketing goals. If you want to drive website traffic or generate leads, email marketing would be better, as it allows you to add more links and/or CTAs. But if you want to create urgency or drive immediate actions, SMS marketing would be more effective.

Once you’ve decided which software to use, head to our email marketing and SMS marketing category pages where you can find a sortable list of products and software reviews from verified users.

How to choose email marketing vs. SMS marketing software

The software you choose should make your marketing team's job easier. Below are a few things to consider when selecting between the two tools:

  1. Evaluate your content needs. If your marketing communication includes detailed content and/or images, opt for email marketing software, as it allows for longer messages and the inclusion of graphics and images. However, if your marketing messages are short and straightforward, go for an SMS marketing platform instead. 

  2. Check customer segmentation functionality. Customer segmentation is crucial to your marketing effort, irrespective of the software you choose. This feature lets you create targeted email or SMS lists to send relevant, personalized messages. Opt for software that allows you to segment your prospects or customers based on location, behavior, interests, etc.

  3. Look for customer opt-in options. Whether choosing email marketing or text message marketing software, select a tool that allows you to add an opt-in option, such as a web form, for customers to subscribe to your messages. Similarly, the tool should let you include opt-out options so customers can choose to unsubscribe from your promotional messages.

Common questions when selecting email marketing vs. SMS marketing software

Here are some questions you should ask software vendors before making a purchase:

Is the software CAN-SPAM compliant?

CAN-SPAM compliance requires all commercial emails and SMS messages from your business to reflect accurate content when promoting products and services and to provide an opt-out mechanism that allows recipients to unsubscribe from future communications.

Does the software help analyze deliverability metrics?

Software that lets you track metrics around message deliverability, such as open rate, click-through rate, and unsubscribe rate, will help measure customer engagement as well as campaign performance. You should also look for a tool that automatically removes invalid email addresses and mobile numbers to help you maintain clean contact lists and improve message deliverability.

Does the software provide the split testing feature?

Split testing, also known as A/B testing, helps optimize your email and text marketing campaigns by creating two versions of a campaign or promotional message and analyzing which version has better audience engagement.


Methodology

For both software categories, we highlight the top five products with the highest average user ratings. To be included in this list, the products had to:

  • Have at least 20 unique product reviews published on Capterra, with an average rating of 3.0 or higher (as of March 20, 2023).

  • Meet our software market definition for email marketing and SMS marketing software:

    • Email marketing software: “Email marketing software helps users leverage their email channel to deliver and optimize marketing messages—such as brand newsletters or contextually relevant, real-time and personalized communications—in support of multichannel engagement across the customer lifecycle.”

    • SMS marketing software: “SMS (text) marketing software provides the tools needed to launch and support text marketing campaigns. Text marketing software can be used to advertise weekly specials, send coupons, solicit feedback, poll customers, and promote contests.”

Disclaimer: The products listed as examples in the features images of each software category are not intended as endorsements or recommendations by Capterra.


Looking for Email Marketing software? Check out Capterra's list of the best Email Marketing software solutions.

Was this article helpful?


About the Author

Ashish Upadhyay profile picture

Ashish Upadhyay is a content writer at Capterra, helping small businesses identify the right software for their business needs by analyzing user reviews data for the highest rated products in relevant software categories. Prior to joining Capterra, he worked in insurtech, fintech, and real estate. Specializing in marketing, project, and IT management, Ashish’s works have been featured in MAST magazine and Medium. In his free time, he enjoys working out and playing video games.

visitor tracking pixel