Fleet Management Software – 5 GPS Tracking Options Compared

Share This Article

0 0 0 0 0 0

Capterra Affiliate Linking Policy

Capterra’s blogs aim to be useful to small business software buyers. Capterra participates in vendor affiliate, referral, and pay-per-click programs where available. This means after a content piece is written by our researchers, our affiliate manager converts existing mentions of vendors into affiliate links where possible and adds PPC links where appropriate. When readers click on those links, sometimes we make a small commission and when they make purchases, sometimes we earn an affiliate fee. That said, we do not accept free products or services from vendors in exchange for mentioning them on the site.

No Capterra blogs or blog posts are sponsored by vendors; further, our writers independently choose which vendors to cover and what to write about them. In fact, most of our writers are unaware of Capterra’s affiliate relationships.

If you have any questions about Capterra’s affiliate policy, including our impartiality or how to get your affiliate links on our editorial content, please email cathy@capterra.com.

UPDATE 10/9/2017: We’ve updated this list to add two new options and include some updated information for the original entries.

With three employees in three trucks, it’s pretty easy to figure out who’s where, if they’re on time, and how much each technician is costing you at the pump. With twenty techs and a dozen vehicles, trying to track all that can get hairy. Luckily, fleet management software can help you keep tabs on everyone.

Across the board, fleet management software is ideal for providing a real-time view of your trucks. You can see where everyone is, track mileage, schedule maintenance, and generate reports based off of usage.

Here is a fleet management software comparison illustrating the ways five of the big players are distinguishing themselves through unique features. All of these options allow GPS integration, making sure you get the most out of your purchase. All of the options on this list have mileage tracking, routing, and vehicle tracking. Results are organized alphabetically.

1. ClearPath GPS

ClearPathGPS’s primary distinguishing feature is their month-to-month contract structure. Rather than getting locked into a multi-year contract, ClearPath’s model provides the flexibility to drop telematics, should you decide you don’t want it (though (ClearPath’s user reviews suggest that most customers do).

A screenshot of a GPS virtual timecard

ClearPathGPS also offers tools that ease a fleet manager’s workload. They offer virtual timecard reports that turn your drivers’ workloads into easily viewed reports. Those timecards can also be exported to your accounting software, cutting down on data entry.

This data ClearPath collects can become part of a comprehensive, strategic overview of your business. ClearPath comes with a library of more than 60 types of visualizations and reports, so you can take the individual details of those virtual timecards (how long was that one driver stopped at his noon delivery site?) and make them part of an overall summary (How long do each of my drivers take at each delivery stop? Who takes the longest?)

2. Fleetmatics

Fleetmatics offers a few twists on the classic fleet management package. First of all, the system centers on drivers, not just trucks. Techs are given key fobs with unique IDs. When they climb into a truck, they tap in. This means that managers can generate reports based off a single driver, no matter how many different trucks they use over the course of a month.


An example of a Fleetmatics dashboard on tablet and desktop

The Fleetmatics system also has a feature called geofencing—we’ll see a lot more of this as we go on that allows managers to expand the area associated with a client or point of interest. For instance, perhaps you service a college campus. Instead of techs having to visit the one spot on the map that “counts” as the college, you can generate an area on the map that encompasses the whole campus. Then, drivers can go where they actually need to go, and the system will record the visit correctly for reporting.

3. GPSTrackIt

While not an entirely cloud-based system, GPS TrackIt has designed a tablet-focused website called Driver, that allows field workers and central office managers to collaborate. The Driver site has a section for messaging, stop scheduling and route planning, and a system for filling out forms. Users can create custom forms for refueling, job management, and updates.


GPS Trackit maps on mobile devices

GPS Trackit offers two devices for monitoring vehicle diagnostics. Users can use either an OBD-II or an under-the-hood solution, helping you preempt breakdowns by interpreting that pesky check engine light. The system also supports geofencing, driver management, and fuel card usage monitoring.

4. Route4Me

Route4Me is another cloud-based fleet management software. The plus side of cloud software? You don’t have to invest in, or maintain, the servers that hold all your information. Route4Me handles all of that, and you get the benefit of the information.

A sample screenshot from Route4Me

Route4Me calls itself the most dynamic fleet management software on the market. Whether that superlative is true, they do update their maps up to thousands of times per hour. If there’s some change to your route, Route4Me is likely to catch it.

Route4Me also has open APIs, or application programming interfaces. Click on that link if you’re interested in what an API is; read on to know what it can do for your fleet. Open APIs let you customize the Route4Me program to your needs (assuming you know how to code, or you’ve got someone who does know on your IT staff). If you have a need the off-the-shelf program can’t meet, you can customize it, as you would a fleet vehicle.

As an example, Route4Me suggests using their open API to integrate their last mile delivery feature with the addresses in your sales software. As a result, you can get the right addresses into Route4Me without worrying about data entry errors.

5. Teletrac Navman

Teletrac Navman is a cloud-based fleet management system. In addition to all the usual features, Teletrac gives users some excellent management tools, including multi-mapping and vehicle diagnostics. Multi-mapping gives dispatchers a way to view up to 20 small maps at once, allowing them to keep a closer eye on individual trucks that would otherwise be lost in a sea of dots.


An example of a Teletrac Navman dashboard

Using add-on devices, Teletrac can also capture and decode engine status updates. Depending on the type of vehicle being managed, you can either plug in an OBD-II compatible tracker or drop a J-Bus enabled device under the hood.

Interested in other GPS tracking software?

Knowing the locations and histories of your trucks and techs is as simple as turning on your computer. Finding the right system for your business is the only hurdle between you and a more efficient process.

For a full listing of options, check out Capterra’s fleet management directory.

If you’re interested in what else fleet management software can do for you, check out one of these Capterra posts:

6 Questions To Ask When Buying Fleet Management Software

The 6 Best Free And Open Source Fleet Management Software Programs

How Fleet Analytics Can Help You With Regulatory Compliance

Looking for Fleet Management software? Check out Capterra's list of the best Fleet Management software solutions.

Share This Article

About the Author

Geoff Hoppe

Geoff Hoppe writes about business intelligence and field service management for Capterra. His background is in education and higher ed, but he’s interested these days in how small businesses can use software to be more agile and efficient. When he’s not reading and writing about software, he’s probably reading and writing about history, music and comic books, finding new hikes throughout Virginia, or following the Fighting Irish.


Very good analysis Andrew. But I think gofleet should be in the list. You can view it here.
In my opinion it is far better than Teletrac and Trimble.

This is a very comprehensive review, thank you. I just wanted to add that in some cases, where GPS signal is low or unavailabe, an alternative solution, like the one featured here: http://www.ocsico.com/solutions/vehicle-tracking-system.html#GPS-alternative-solution might be very useful.
Best regards,

Check out ClearPathGPS! No contracts, cancel or suspend anytime. Plans are $20 per month. Professionally installed and fully warrantied!

I already tried using several mileage tracking app before. They are working just fine, just how a mileage tracking app should be. But a friend told me to try MileGo. I first used it on a business trip, and I am really impressed. It’s awesome. You might also want to try it, I’m sure you’ll be impressed too.

Nice Blog!!
Fleet management and GPS tracking go hand in hand and both together can help fleet companies achieve their business goals. Focusing on fleet management is very important for any transport company to maximize the profit. Fleet vehicle tracking devices can provide support in the overall fleet management and give endless benefits and opportunities to the business.

I would like to say that the industries should stop using GPS instead they should try Beacons for granular visibility of their products/assets

Of all the above, i think my favourite software is route4me as it updates maps thousands of times per hour plus you dont have to spend on servers as the software will take care of it for you.

Comment on this article:

Your privacy is important to us. Check out our Privacy Policy.